RFC 1131: likely-intrinsic

lang (hint | optimization | intrinsic)

Summary

Provide a pair of intrinsic functions for hinting the likelyhood of branches being taken.

Motivation

Branch prediction can have significant effects on the running time of some code. Especially tight inner loops which may be run millions of times. While in general programmers aren't able to effectively provide hints to the compiler, there are cases where the likelyhood of some branch being taken can be known.

For example: in arbitrary-precision arithmetic, operations are often performed in a base that is equal to 2^word_size. The most basic division algorithm, "Schoolbook Division", has a step that will be taken in 2/B cases (where B is the base the numbers are in), given random input. On a 32-bit processor that is approximately one in two billion cases, for 64-bit it's one in 18 quintillion cases.

Detailed design

Implement a pair of intrinsics likely and unlikely, both with signature fn(bool) -> bool which hint at the probability of the passed value being true or false. Specifically, likely hints to the compiler that the passed value is likely to be true, and unlikely hints that it is likely to be false. Both functions simply return the value they are passed.

The primary reason for this design is that it reflects common usage of this general feature in many C and C++ projects, most of which define simple LIKELY and UNLIKELY macros around the gcc __builtin_expect intrinsic. It also provides the most flexibility, allowing branches on any condition to be hinted at, even if the process that produced the branched-upon value is complex. For why an equivalent to __builtin_expect is not being exposed, see the Alternatives section.

There are no observable changes in behaviour from use of these intrinsics. It is valid to implement these intrinsics simply as the identity function. Though it is expected that the intrinsics provide information to the optimizer, that information is not guaranteed to change the decisions the optimiser makes.

Drawbacks

The intrinsics cannot be used to hint at arms in match expressions. However, given that hints would need to be variants, a simple intrinsic would not be sufficient for those purposes.

Alternatives

Expose an expect intrinsic. This is what gcc/clang does with __builtin_expect. However there is a restriction that the second argument be a constant value, a requirement that is not easily expressible in Rust code. The split into likely and unlikely intrinsics reflects the strategy we have used for similar restrictions like the ordering constraint of the atomic intrinsics.

Unresolved questions

None.